mind body mama: Holding You Up
As in, "Since dinner's going to be a little late, I'll have an apple to hold me up."
A perfect storm of power failure, family tragedy, and holiday traffic conspired to keep me from the blog this weekend. While I'm working on a post to convey the sadness and silliness of our Thanksgiving, I offer you this essay to hold you up. It's a companion to my post of a few weeks back, Nothing Lucky About It.
Not Unlucky Neither
So we’re clear on the concept that luck is not what gets most women through an attack situation.
More like grit, determination, survival instinct, fighting skills, strategy and courage.
But what about how they found themselves in those situations to begin with? Absent the ever popular victim blaming—she shouldn’t have been there/worn that/ fill in the blank—is it just bad luck?
“She was in the wrong place at the wrong time.”
I say no. I say that when we ascribe the cause of an attack to bad luck we miss a crucial piece of accountability. In that place, at that time, somebody chose to attack her.
It’s bad luck to walk down the hall and stumble over your own shoelace. It’s someone else’s crappy, mean-spirited, effed-up choice if he sticks his foot out and trips you.
I am not a researcher, not a social worker, not an expert in the psychology of violent perpetrators. I know it could be argued that some attackers are not fully in their right minds. Perhaps some are actually unable to make a better choice than to assault someone.
And I do understand that those who witness or experience violence are considered more likely to become perpetrators themselves.
But if you think about the statistics on violence, such as these that I borrowed from Erin Weed:
• For every 1,000 persons age 12 or older, there occurs: 1 rape or sexual assault, 1 assault with injury, 3 robberies. (US Department of Justice, 2005)
• Up to 47% of women report that their first sexual intercourse was forced. (WHO 2002)
and these that I borrowed from The National Coaliton Against Domestic Violence:
• An estimated 1.3 million women are victims of physical assault by an intimate partner each year (CDC 2003).
• One in 6 women and 1 in 33 men have experienced an attempted or completed rape (US Department of Justice, 1998).
you very rapidly come to the conclusion that there are an awful lot of attackers out there.
And I have to think that some of them are people who who could do better.
Men who could refrain from hitting their intimate partners.
Men who could recognize that inability to explictly refuse sexual contact— due to inebriation, for example— is not the same as actually granting consent.
Men who could take responsibility for their own anger and not visit it upon their families.
Men who could refuse the culture’s definition of masculinity as inherently violent.
Men who could refuse the culture’s definition of the female body as their object.
Men who could take control of themselves—instead of the women around them.
My National Women’s Martial Arts Federation colleague Deborah Schipper asks, “What’s the difference between going somewhere and getting raped and going to the same place and not getting raped?”
“It’s the RAPIST in the room!” is her answer.
It’s natural to ponder the trials that come at us in this life, to wonder how our lives are fated or directed. But I’m giving credit where credit is due. It’s not lucky when a woman fights back successfully, it’s a triumphant of spirit. And it’s not unlucky when an asshole assaults, it’s a criminal choice.
Labels: feminism, self-defense




